Mac icon changer apps compared
There are a handful of ways to give Mac apps new icons. They differ on three things that matter in practice: whether they can touch Apple's own apps, whether your icons survive app updates, and how many icons you have to set by hand. Here's what each one does, based on each maker's own site (linked) and, for Iconic, the app itself.
| Get Info (Finder) | Iconic | Replacicon | Pictogram | IconChamp | LiteIcon / CandyBar | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Price | Free, built in | $9.99 once, 2 Macs | One-time payment (amount not listed on its site) | Free (beta) | Free core; paid Pro tier (~$10) | Free (discontinued) |
| Works on current macOS | Yes | macOS 13 and later | macOS 13 and later | Not stated | Targets Big Sur / Monterey; broken on Tahoe | Discontinued (Mojave/Catalina and older) |
| Apple's built-in apps (Safari, Mail…) | No (read-only system volume) | Yes, for pinned Dock apps via wrapper (Finder & Trash excluded) | Not stated | No | Used to, requires workarounds / broken on newer macOS | No on Big Sur and later |
| Keeps icons after app updates | No, reapply by hand | Yes, reapplies automatically | Yes | Yes | Not stated | — |
| Built-in icon library | No, bring your own PNG | 30,000+ icons, searchable | Thousands of alternate icons | Not stated | No | No |
| Theme many apps at once | No | Yes, 20 style collections | Not stated | Not stated | Themes support | No |
| Folder icons | Yes | Yes | Not stated | Not stated | Yes | System icons only |
| Other | — | Fixes gray Tahoe squircles in one click; light & dark slots | AI icon generation with Apple Intelligence | — | Official site (iconchamp.com) offline | CandyBar unsupported since 2012 |
"Not stated" means the maker's site doesn't say, not that the feature is missing. Checked November 2026. Sources: Apple (Get Info), replacicon.app, pictogramapp.com, macenhance.com, freemacsoft.net/liteicon.
Which one to use
- Changing one or two third-party apps, once: Get Info is free and fine. Step-by-step guide.
- Icons that keep resetting after updates: you need an app that reapplies them. Iconic, Replacicon and Pictogram all say they do.
- Safari, Mail, Notes and other built-in Apple apps: Get Info and Pictogram can't. Iconic does it by putting a wrapper app carrying your icon in the Dock (Finder and Trash are drawn by the Dock itself and cannot be changed by any tool).
- Replacing CandyBar, LiteIcon or IconChamp on Sequoia / Tahoe: CandyBar and LiteIcon are discontinued, and IconChamp was built for Big Sur/Monterey and breaks on newer macOS icon formats. Iconic supports macOS 13 through macOS 26 Tahoe.
- A whole matching Dock: Iconic applies a full style collection in one go. You can browse every icon free in the catalog before buying.
- Gray squircles on macOS Tahoe: see the squircle fix.
Iconic is our app, so read this table with that in mind; everything said about the others comes from their own pages.
FAQ
What is the best free way to change app icons on Mac?
Finder's Get Info: select the app, press Command-I and drop a PNG onto the small icon. It doesn't work on Apple's built-in apps and the icon resets when the app updates.
What is the best CandyBar or LiteIcon alternative for modern macOS?
CandyBar (discontinued 2012) and LiteIcon (stopped at Catalina) no longer work on modern macOS. For free manual swaps use Finder Get Info, or use Iconic ($9.99 once) or Replacicon if you want automatic re-apply after updates.
Which icon changer works with Apple apps like Safari?
Get Info and Pictogram can't change apps that ship with macOS. Iconic changes pinned Dock tiles for built-in apps like Safari and Mail by placing a small wrapper app with your icon in the Dock (Finder and Trash cannot be changed).
Why do custom Mac icons reset?
An app update replaces the app bundle and the custom icon with it. Iconic, Replacicon and Pictogram reapply icons after updates.